Advantages and disadvantages of Wi-Fi Direct

Advantages and disadvantages of Wi-Fi Direct

Wi-Fi Direct is a wireless communication technology based on the Wi-Fi standard and 802.11 networking standard that allows enabled devices to connect with each other directly without requiring a wireless access point or a wireless router and Internet connection. This technology essentially allows the creation of a personal Wi-Fi network for direct communication.

Pros: Benefits and Advantages of Wi-Fi Direct

1. Direct Wireless Connectivity

A notable advantage of Wi-Fi Direct is that connection is direct. Although it is based on the same standards used in Wi-Fi or WLAN networks, establishing a connection using this technology does not require an access point or a wireless router and Wi-Fi hotspot. An enabled device is essentially a personal Wi-Fi network. Note that Wi-Fi Direct does not require an Internet connection as well. This technology also supports bootstrapping using Near Field Communication or NFC technology.

2. Flexible and Versatile Applications

Take note that Wi-Fi Direct is somehow similar to Bluetooth technology. Enabled devices are capable of communicating directly with one another for transferring data, synchronization, and other interfacing purposes. Specific applications of Wi-Fi Direct include sending and receiving files, displaying information from computers to an enabled display monitor or play media from one device to an output, wireless printing, and play multiplayer games across different devices.

3. Better and Faster Data Transfer Rate

Another notable advantage of Wi-Fi Direct when compared to Bluetooth is that it has a faster data transfer rate. The technology supports a transfer speed of up to 250 Mbps while the current version of Bluetooth has a transfer speed of up to 25 Mbps only. In addition, when compared further to Bluetooth, Wi-Fi Direct has a longer range. It has a maximum theoretical distance of 656 feet while Bluetooth 4.0 has a maximum theoretical distance of 200 feet. These advantages make Wi-Fi Direct a more reliable option for sharing large files and data-intensive or bandwidth-critical interfacing.

4. Compatible With Legacy Wi-Fi Devices

It is also important to mention that Wi-Fi Direct is also backward compatible. Wi-Fi Direct devices will be able to communicate with legacy Wi-Fi devices or non-Wi-Fi Direct devices. For example, a laptop or smartphone equipped with a Wi-Fi Direct chip can establish a connection with devices such as printers or monitors that have old Wi-Fi chips.

5. Secure Connectivity

Connections established through Wi-Fi Direct are protected by WPA2 security protocol and certification. Also, although connections are direct, a user cannot randomly connect to another enabled device because this wireless technology uses key-based encryption and authentication methods that are similar to Bluetooth technology. Users need to undergo a setup process to establish a connection via this technology. Nonetheless, these features offer substantial security for average users. Take note that future Wi-Fi Direct devices will feature WPA3 that provides better security measures than WPA2.

Cons: Limitations and Disadvantages of Wi-Fi Direct

1. Slower Than Wired Connectivity

A considerable disadvantage of Wi-Fi Direct, when compared to wired connectivity, is slower transfer speed. Of course, wire-based hardware interfaces such as USB 3.0 and Thunderbolt technology offer better and faster data transfer rates than Wi-Fi Direct and other wireless connectivity technologies. Take note that USB 3.0 has a transfer rate of 640 Mbps while Thunderbolt supports two 10 Gbps channels. It is also important to highlight the fact that the maximum 250 Mbps transfer speed of Wi-Fi Direct is theoretical because it does not take into consideration other factors such as device-specific capabilities and interferences.

2. Connectivity Issues Due to Compatibility

Establishing a wireless connection between Wi-Fi Direct devices and even with non-Wi-Fi Direct devices should be hassle-free. However, there are numerous user-reported issues available online claiming problems with connecting two or more enabled devices. These issues seem to be more common in enabled smartphones from different manufacturers and printers. Possibly, these compatibility problems stem from the specific technical implementations of device manufacturers.

3. Power Consumption and Energy Efficiency

The Wi-Fi Alliance noted that Wi-Fi Direct promises energy efficiency through better power management. However, the fact remains that this technology operates in the 2.4 GHz frequency band of the ultra-high frequency or microwave electromagnetic spectrum. Generating this frequency consumes more power than other wireless technologies such as Near Field Communication or Bluetooth Low Energy. In addition, using Wi-Fi Direct for extended period shortens the battery charge of an enabled device beyond its standard standby and operational times.

4. Still Has Some Security Vulnerabilities

Remember that Wi-Fi Direct uses the WPA security and certification protocols to establish and maintain a secure connection. Connecting devices via this technology usually requires entering an eight-digit numerical WPS PIN. However, pin-based authentication method can be subjected to brute force attacks. Some enabled devices have a default PINs that can be exploited easily if users have failed to apply necessary modifications. Also, hackers can also access the Wi-Fi network and WLAN via the Wi-Fi Direct hardware of vulnerable enabled devices such as printers. These hackers use the connection via Wi-Fi Direct to convince an enabled device to route from Wi-Fi to a local area network.